Spotsylvania County: McGuire Statement on GM Powertrain Plant Closing

4 Jun
Click the image for McGuire website.

Click the image for McGuire website.

D.J. McGuire, Republican nominee for the Lee Hill Supervisor, released this statement in reaction to the announced closing of GM’s Powertrain plant on Tidewater Trail.

Like many other Spotsylvanians, I was disappointed by the news of the closing of General Motors’ Powertrain plant.  I see the plant every day on my way home from work, and it has been a symbol of the county’s openness to success in industry and prosperity for its citizens.  I am sad to see its apparent demise.  Just three years ago, GM was investing more capital into the Powertrain factory, so this action also comes as a surprise.  Given GM’s current status, I hope and expect that both the company and the Obama Administration will be very open about the reasoning behind this decision.

Of course, GM is in need of serious adjustment, and no one can be certain what action, if any, the county could have taken that would have led to a different outcome.  However, this is a good time for Spotsylvania to reflect on its recent actions, which certainly didn’t improve the outlook for business in general or the Tidewater Trail plant in particular.

Since GM’s last infusion of capital into the Powertrain plant, property taxes were raised 11% (on average); the personal property tax rate was raised more than 25%; and the business furniture/fixture tax rate was raised 19%.  While avoidance of these recession-aggravating measures may not have saved Powertrain, at the very least it would have reduced the risk and the cost to GM for keeping it open – and would certainly do the same for future users of that space.  Moreover, if (however unlikely the possibility) the plant was closed for more political reasons, the aforementioned tax increases could very well provide Washington with some of the justification it would use to claim otherwise.  It certainly won’t help the future users of that plant, or any other businesses struggling to get through this recession here in Spotsylvania.

In any event, it is time for Spotsylvania to recognize its place in the national and global community, and to acknowledge that it cannot over-tax, over-spend, and over-regulate in a vacuum.  That is why, should I be elected Lee Hill Supervisor this November, I will:

  • Refuse to support any real estate tax rate above equalization
  • Keep a close eye on county spending to avoid future tax increases and where possible allow for reductions in tax rates, be it for real estate, BPOL, furniture/fixtures, machinery/tools, heavy equipment, personal property, etc.
  • Work with my fellow Supervisors and the Planning Commission to scale back (and, if possible, repeal) the recently imposed commercial design standards (a.k.a. the “HCOD design standards”) as soon as practicable

The GM Powertrain plant may stay open until late next year.  I cannot say whether or not the above plans will save it – and truth be told, it would not be sensible to bend county policy simply to aid one employer.  However, we can (and I believe we must) use this as a wake-up call to make Spotsylvania a friendlier county for established and rising businesses – including the business that is and/or will be at 11032 Tidewater Trail.

For more information, contact D.J. at

3 Responses to “Spotsylvania County: McGuire Statement on GM Powertrain Plant Closing”

  1. Kyle June 5, 2009 at 10:15 am #

    Or GM makes cars that no one wants. Only GM is to blame for their own demise. While Toyota and Honda were investing in hybrid and electric car technology, GM was building bigger trucks and SUVs. GM had a 10 year head start on electric cars and they threw it away.

    GM is bankrupt today because they pursued short term profits from SUVs at the expense of long term planning.

  2. Michael June 5, 2009 at 11:04 pm #

    Kyle, I don’t think anyone is arguing that GM was well managed.

  3. Isabelle June 15, 2009 at 10:19 am #

    No Surprise that GM had to sink like the Titanic.. Just the pain and hard work of 300 Million Taxpayers going down the drain.. Whose responsible for that?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: